I have scanned all twelve pages (each one in two parts, 24 scans overall) and I'm currently uploading them to my Flickr account here. For a little preview, here are the opening two paragraphs:
Tibet, located in southwest China, has since the ancient times been an inalienable part of China. Before the Democratic Reform in 1959, Tibet had long been a society of feudal serfdom featuring the despotic temporal and religious administration, a society which was darker and more cruel than the European serfdom of the Middle Ages. The People's Republic of China was founded in 1949, and in 1951, Tibet won peaceful liberation. The Central Government was prudent with regard to the reform of old Tibet and adopted a tolerant attitude toward the local government of Tibet. With great patience and sincerity, the Central Government did its best to talk to the upper ruling class in Tibet and waited for it to conduct reform of the old system of its own accord. However, the reactionary clique of the upper social strata of Tibet tried to preserve for ever the feudal serfdom featuring temporal and religious administration, and in March 1959 launched an armed rebellion with the aim of tearing Tibet away from the motherland. The Central Government, with the support of the people in Tibet, dissolved the local government of Tibet which rode roughshod over the broad masses of the Tibetans and resolutely suppressed the armed rebellion. At this same time, the Central Government, responding to the will of the Tibetan people, implemented the Democratic Reform and abolished the feudal serf system featuring temporal and religious administration that had lasted for several centuries. During the Democratic Reform, one million serfs and slaves in Tibet won emancipation, Tibet entered into a new era of social development, and the Tibetan people stood up and came into their own. In order to mark this historic event, the People's Congress of the Tibet Autonomous Region decided on January 19, 2009 that March 28, the day in 1959 the Central Government ordered the disorganization of the local government of old Tibet, be the "Serf Emancipation Day" of Tibet.
To mark the 50th anniversary of the Democratic Reform in Tibet, this photo exhibition is held to show its great cause and the changes that have taken place to Tibet over the past 50 years; it is also aimed at helping the international community gain a better understanding of the history and present situation of Tibet.
I have been told by the paper's Advertising Manager that the Chinese Embassy in Malawi is responsible for the ad. I managed to contact the Managing Editor of the paper as well, and I asked him why they printed an advertisement designed to disguise itself as editorial content, and why, instead of clarifying that it was indeed advertising, the paper thought it necessary to incorporate their own logo into the layout of the advertising spread - thereby giving the impression that this advertising content was, in fact, approved by the Daily Times of being "worthy" of its brand. The managing editor insisted that the text reading "ADVERTISING" in the corner of each page provided all the necessary clarification.
When asked whether anyone who wanted could write up a news story - no matter its truth or falsehood - and run it in his paper as advertising, the Managing Editor told me no - there are standards in place, and each advertisement is carefully screened to see if it is worthy of being printed in The Daily Times. The Chinese Embassy's advertisement, he said, passed this test.
At this point, he began to make some accusations. He accused me of trying to get him sacked from his job, of hating the Chinese, and of being from Tibet myself (though I speak with an American accent) - or being a covert agent of Tibet.
"Were you in China at that time [referred to in the ad]? How do you know what they were doing?" he asked me, more than once. He also told me "the Dalai Lama has had his own mishaps in the past," citing as his one example the Dalai Lama's recent denial of a visa by the South African government.
I'll let you all be the judge of whether I am, in fact, a Tibetan agent. In the meantime, if you have something you'd like to say to the Editorial Office of The Daily Times, they can be contacted at dailytimes@bnl.bppmw.com.
As with everything, according to myself, it all goes back to the Mongols. When the Mongols conquered and united the northern and southern Chinese kingdoms and Kublai Khan founded the Yuan dynasty, they were pretty friendly with the Tibetans, who also had nomadic turkic steppe traditions. Those officials who weren't Mongols were not infrequently Tibetans, and this rankled the Chinese. Furthermore, the Mongols got really into the more unusual and Tantric elements of Tibetan Buddhism, which made the "barbarian" invaders seem even more alien. Ever since then, China has never had a good relationship with Tibet, and has always been eager to claim it as a permanent tributary state.
ReplyDeleteGo John! You get that FP Passport shout-out!
ReplyDeleteWhat's a big fuss you are making here? I read Tibetan propaganda all the time in U.S. Don't always assume what you believe in is the truth and what you don't believe in is not the truth. The treatment of American Indian is worse than the treatment of Tibetan. Japan has yet to apologize to those sex slaves. There are countless such examples. But you are agitated by this advertisement. You mindset is so narrow and you are blind-fooled by your 'superior' understanding of this world. Now you can assume that 1.3 billion of Chinese people are brainwashed by CCP's propaganda and then go peacefully to your bed with a smile on your face.
ReplyDelete@anonymous Well, it seems a little odd to me that China sees it as very important that the people of a small southern African country hear their side of the story for for what sounds like a large portion of the newspaper.
ReplyDeleteWhat happened to the American Indians and what the Japanese did were both terrible, but they don't excuse further action any more than the fact that the Cambodian genocide was numerically smaller than the Holocaust gives the people currently on trial there any excuse. The US no longer slaughters Indians, we know to stop. Since China is obviously so knowledgeable of others' faults, you'd think it would recognize and take action against its own.
Its a 21st century. Please don't compare Tibetans' suffering to anyone. Suffering is suffering.
ReplyDeleteSuffering is suffering. But how can you be so sure of such suffering? Is it from BBC or CNN?
ReplyDeleteits neither from BBC nor CNN, its from the Tibetans themselves. What would you know of sufferings, and what the Tibetan people are undergoing.
ReplyDeleteI have one quiestion.why International media and tourist are not allowd in Tibet,if there is nothing to hide.
ReplyDeleteI am Tibetan from inside Tibet.We tiberan are becoming minority in our own place.There is culturel geocide day by day.I agree with swati.why Chinese are not allowing international media to see what happening inside Tibet.We tibetan are always living with fear.Even there is some development done there but its all for chinese interest and also whose expenses they did that development?They have expolited Tibetan land for rich minerals.So please don't belive in communist chinese propaganda its lies.They have brutelly Murdered 1.2 million Tibetans.So watch out for those red communist
ReplyDeleteI am also a Tibetan and I have my family in Tibet. The situation inside Tibet right now is very disturbing and difficult. Everyone lives with fear and suspicion. The whole plateau is completely closed with a huge military build up. When my sister in Lhasa calls me, she does from different phone booth at different times in order to not become a suspect. She said Tibetans are suffering without freedom. I guess thats what it means by being emancipated. Thanks to China's occupation. Open Tibet and let the world see Tibet for themselves. If there is no problem, if people are happy then the Chinese government should have no problem showing to the world. I want more outsiders to visit Tibet and see for themselves what is happening. Don't watch just CNN and BBC. Go there and see with your own eyes. And also for the Chinese don't just watch CCTV. Go there and try to find out what Tibet and Tibetans really are. You will then respect plight of Tibetans.
ReplyDeleteChina propaganda says seeing is believing. After March 10, 2008 they don't want the world to see what is happening in Tibet but they want to spend more money on the propaganda making people believe by reading.
ReplyDeleteSuch propaganda is good because now people would take interest in reading the other side of the story also and make judgment. Chian often have accused the Dalai Lama for internationalizing the issue. We are happy that they are doing the same for the Dalai Lama. Truth comes out anyway.
dorjee
this was observant...
ReplyDeleteso international propoganda is alive and well in malawi.
in the fact the red china govt is a shameless and teh chinese people are same as a bird the teh cage. they have any chance to see out side of his or her cage. also they have any idea the cage is good or not.
ReplyDelete@ 1st Anonymous - If the US government took out a large, editorial-style ad in a Malawian newspaper about how much better American Indians are now than under the tyranny of their despotic local chieftains, who imposed "temporal and religious administration" against the public will, he'd probably write about that too.
ReplyDeleteThank you Duffel. I am a tibetan myself. I am bit disturbed by What China is tryig to do here? They think with money they can buy anything. Lots of money being poured into Africa with the plan to convert them to Communist Idealogy. If China is that great and truthful then why are they scare of journalist and freedom?
ReplyDeleteThats all we are asking.
Isn't it interesting for China, a country who claims that Tibet has been part of China for atleast 700 years to still feel the need to make this assertion always? The truth is, these claims are simply new invention of the 20th Century China. There are far greater similarities between Chinese and Koreans and Japanese than there is with the Tibetans.
ReplyDeleteHistory will show how brutal the Chinese regime in Tibet has been. After the lessons of Holocaust and Apartheid, let us not be on the wrong side again. Let us stand up for the rights of the Tibetan people.
What is China hiding in Tibet?
Editor
ReplyDeleteThe Daily Times,
Malavi.
Please refer to your unusual article/news/editorial/paid ads- ‘Democratic Reforms in Tibet’. It is pathetic that responsible media like- The Daily Times could stoop to such a low by publishing the biased and far fetched article, that too in a very deceptive manner. Almost every people of conscious and responsible media on this planet condemn China for invading Tibet and its wrongful policy.
Old Tibet may be feudal and oppressed, but it was far better than the current Tibet under Communist regime. In 1950s, the whole world was reeling under the world war-II where people kill one another. Cities were in rubbles. People had no foods to eat. Millions were dying in China due to starvation. In Europe, women were ready to sleep with anyone who could offer her a piece of bread to eat. However, Tibet didn’t take part in the war. Its people how much oppressed they were had at least something to eat and practice their religion and faith freely. Moreover, feudalism was a story of every society at one point of time. Do you think it is justified to invade simply in the name of liberation? Tibet’s southern border touching India, Nepal and Bhutan by then was deprived of any border patrols. However, not a single Tibetan crossed in the name of seeking political asylum in the neighboring countries. When the communist China marched into Tibet in the late 1940s, more than 2000 Tibetans crosses (nowadays fully patrolled) border to seek asylum in the neighboring countries every year. All these and more clearly shows that old Tibet how much oppressed it might be were far better than the current Tibet.
The editor and your team members, SHAME ON YOU.
With best wishes,
tashi wangchuk
www.tibetanfilms.com
Thank you Mr Duffell for standing up and exposing what is Chinese dictatorship's imperial and genocidal plan to wipe out the ancient and unique Tibetan nation from the earth.
ReplyDeleteI am sure that all African people will learn the truth and see how Chinese dictatorship is actually worse than those past historical European or Arab colonizers.
Like they have done for 2000 years, the Chinese regimes know no remorse and they always wipe out indigenous populations and all of their identity and replace them with obedient robots. Then they expand again!
Africa is free!
Bhoe Rangzen! Free Tibet!
Hi,
ReplyDeleteIt was great of you to expose this fraudulent act of the Chinese government. It may have been a Malawi paper this time, next it may be something bigger.
Time to nip it in the bud. Let work to limit CCP propaganda to CCTV and Xinhua. Write to the editors of these newspapers and let them feel the dissatisfaction of the masses.
Today we got a similar treat in India. A 4 page Ad with Hindustan Times, India's leading newspaper. Really Sad!
ReplyDeleteThe CCP Are trying to control the world. For Gods sake people wake up. This is not just about Tibet any more. These are the barbarians predicted in Tibetan texts. They are practicing their evil tricks on the ignorant and not so ignorant but also the greedy - hence the buy up of American bonds. They own America. Then they prey on the weaker countries like New Zealand - and the weak politicians get sucked in.Bad luck for us - the Government sold our collective soul to the devil. People do believe what they read. Such is ignorance. I have been to Tibet twice and I have seen the destruction and the control and the suffering of the Tibetans.
ReplyDeleteOnly an insane person will agree to Chinese repression in Tibet. Communist regime may make up their own history with their vast wealth to fool the world.
ReplyDeleteWhat do CCP think? World is stupid!
Shame on editor of The Daily Times in Malawi. Now the ad's on Hindustan Times too.
Support truth by not endorsing those who publish lies.
SAVE TIBET
FREE TIBET
Comments from another blog:
ReplyDelete# Anoni | April 9th, 2009 | 4:16 pm
O yea….only 7 out of 16 of Dalai Lama siblings survived to adulthood.
5 dalai lamas from 1800? to 1880? died too young and never really took his throne.
Khampas and Goloks were notorious bandits. Kampas hated the Lhasa officials and wanted to overthrow the Lhasa governments.
Monasteries fought against monasteries…and one appealed to Lhasa, the other appealed to Han-Chinese warlords.
It this not living hell??
The CCP united them all….Praise to CCP.
But praise to Lord Jesus, the name above all names.
32. Anonimous | Your comment is awaiting moderation. April 10th, 2009 | 11:37 am
35 per cent life expectancy comes from Tom Grunfeld’s book.
Talk about human evils.
Your Living Buddha Taktra Rinpoche dared to kill the Dalai Lama’s father. If the PLA had not enter Tibet, the Dalai Lama would probably also be killed by Taktra Rinpoche. The PLA saved the Dalai Lama’s life because it created a sense of crisis, which caused Taktra Rinpoche to be dethroned.
Your Living Buddha Taktra Rinpoche dared to kill Living Buddha Reting.
Khampas people dared to kill the peace emissary the Living Buddha Geda Lama sent by the CCP.
Your monasteries fought against monasteries; one side called Lhasa for help; the other called the Han-Chinese warlord for help. In another case, one side called Lhasa, the other side called the Hui (Muslim) warlord.
In the period 1917-1920 and 1930-1933, there were 400-500 battles at the border regions. Khampas fighting against Chinese warlords; Khampas fighting against Lhasa; Khampas fighting Khampas.
1933 after Dalai Lama died, Pangda brothers rebelled against Lhasa but was suppressed brutally.
Later around 1935, Red Army arrived, converting a big monastery and thousands of monks, with a great number of followers, and setting up Boba Republics under the leadership of Red Army. Lhasa went into alliance with KMT forces to fight the Red Army.
Tibetans+KMT fought against Tibetans+Communists…According to Jamyang Norbu, even after 1949, right up to 1952.
The CCP united them all. Khampas united with CCP, Lhasa united with CCP, Goloks united with CCP, KMT remnants united with CCP. Those who did not want to unite flee to Taiwan. Later, to Dharamsalem. Those who remained stayed united, defeating the Sichuan Earthquake and the exiles’ plot to destabilize Tibet through the Lhasa riots of 2008.
35 per cent life expectancy comes from Tom Grunfeld’s book. 90 per cent suffered from venereal diseases. One third suffered from Smallpox.
13th Dalai Lama suffered from smallpox also.
Declining population over the centuries - what can you against that? That’s hellish. You cannot say it is because of high monk population because you practised polygamy extensively; and your gals did not need to be formally married to bear children.
And you guys are supposedly peaceful, so it cannot be due to wars nor due to murder.
Moreover, it is almost always that other ethnic groups fought the war for you.
So, unless you guys provide a good explanation for declining population - from Mighty Tibet Empire to the “Demise of the Lamaist State” - I have to conclude, pre-1950 Tibet is living hell.
[The PLA are angels to Tibetans in the 1950s]
33. Anonimous | Your comment is awaiting moderation. April 10th, 2009 | 4:38 pm
Robert Webster Ford, a Briton who was present during the Chinese invasion of Tibet in 1950, wrote in 1957 an eye-witness account of how the Chinese treated Tibetans who fought them. (Ford was employed by the Tibetan local government when the Tibetan town Chamdo was captured by the PLA in 1950. He had been under investigation for espionage activities and for causing the death of Geda Lama, a prominent Tibetan Living Buddha and peace emissary sent by the Communist Chinese to Tibet to negotiate for peaceful unification. His death contributed to the Chinese decision to capture Chamdo by force).[43]
There was no sacking of monasteries…the Chinese took great care not to cause offense through ignorance…The Chinese had made it clear that they had no quarrel with the Tibetan religion. Nor with the Tibetan people, who were treated with equal care…
Cleverest of all was the way the Chinese solved their prisoner-of-war problem. They simply had the Tibetan troops lined up and gave them all safe-conduct passes and money and told them to go back to Lhasa with their wives and children. Another newsreel was made of this, and the soldiers did not have to be told to smile. Nor would they need to be told to spread the news of what friendly people the Chinese were… [44]
A Khamba survivor of the garrison of fifty told us…”They are strange people, these Chinese…I cut off eight of their heads with my sword, and they just let me go.” [44]
“History is a maiden,” runs a Chinese saying,” and you can dress her up however you please”. Like the sayings, Chinese official historians recorded distorted past events to please the emperors and rulers. Over the centuries China, one of the leading civilization and polity on earth, has developed a culture of deceiving its own people and now they want the world to believe it. The past history, according to them, was a history of “Han and Barbarians”. Therefore, the aggressors want the Tibetans to be grateful for the great favor they claim to have done by liberating them from the imperialist initially and later from feudal lords, as the original excuse failed.
ReplyDeleteYou said that “PLA are angels for Tibetan in 1950”. Have you ever heard in any fairy tales or in reality that angels come with guns?
J Dorji
Dear JOhn, thank you for posting the same in FP.
ReplyDeletem here via FP.
In India as well, one of the most popular national newspaper THE HINDU acts as a substitute mouthpiece for CCP. i.e glorifies China's "achievement" and neglects anything scandalous newsreport which might put China in a badlight. Yes, very selective newsreporting and there have been several occasions where the editor in chief who owns the paper writes in open-ed for a consecutive days on the "development" and prosperity in Tibet.
oh yes, he goes to China very often.
its sad, very sad when media is hands in glove with anyone who commits aggression. it defeats the whole purpose of making 'aware' and bringing truth to the people.
I was the person named "anoni..." who posted some of the above passages in a Tibetan website. I was banned from posting (target of censorship), so I used different names starting with "anoni".
ReplyDeleteI hope the blogger will read through them carefully and rethink about China and China's Tibet.
Reading only one side of the story will not help you attain the truth.
Here are some more pieces I want to recommend you:
(1)Popularity of China-installed Panchen Lama
http://bbs.chinadaily.com.cn/viewthread.php?gid=2&tid=678992&extra=page%3D1
(scroll down)
(2) Dalai Lama approved of Tibetan troops fighting Pakistan War
http://bbs.chinadaily.com.cn/search.php?searchid=159608&orderby=lastpost&ascdesc=desc&searchsubmit=yes
(3)Who can believe that Dalai Lama was not behind Lhasa Riots?
http://bbs.chinadaily.com.cn/viewthread.php?tid=649040&fpage=1&highlight=%2Bmatthew5%5C_3
(4)Interesting stories Americans Don't Know (Panchen Lama 9th, 10th, 11th)
http://bbs.chinadaily.com.cn/viewthread.php?gid=2&tid=663073 (scroll down)
Google Book That Provides A Different Perspective:
The historical status of China's Tibet
By Jiawei Wang, Nimajianzan
This is a response to the Tibetan from Tibet above. Obviously he is a fake. The international media was not allowed to enter Tibet only for a short period after the Lhasa riots of 2008. The Chinese were used to Soviet and NOT Western media practice, that's why. But they have since realized that they need to connect with the West and the World. Restriction to enter has been lifted for at least 2 years. Fake Tibetan from Tibet above is discredited.
ReplyDeleteJoker Tibetans. The Sichuan Earthquake (May 2008) and Yushu Earthquake (2009) were both Tibetan-majority regions. And reporters from all over the world have been reporting on-the-spot furiously.
ReplyDeleteAs for military buildup, it was during the period March 2009 when the Chinese got winds that the exiles were plotting another riots to commemorate their 50th anniversary of "resistance". It was a necessary and TEMPORARY precaution after when happened in March 2008. This year (2010), the military measure was not necessary.
On history.
ReplyDeleteOne guy above talks about Chinese writing deceiving histories. I want people here to know, all that I have written above about pre-1950 Tibet are gathered from Western sources. None was Han-Chinese. And they were all academics from Western universities, and some of them were Tibetan exiles.
Historically, the Chinese did not write history while they or their dynasty were still alive. It was the NEXT dynasty that wrote the history of the previous dynasty. They had nothing or little to cover up or glorify -- because there were neither rewards nor shame as it mostly did not involve them or their dynasty.
[You said that “PLA are angels for Tibetan in 1950”. Have you ever heard in any fairy tales or in reality that angels come with guns?]
ReplyDeleteIn "fairy tale" times, angels came with swords. Definitely, the angels put their swords to use in the way swords were designed for. During those times, guns have not been invented.
Now they probably come with their flying saucers or similar UFO armed with high-energy laser beams.
Reality is real. Angels must get their work done. Swords or lasers.